Start with Our Diamond Quiz
Natural vs. Cultured Pearl Price & Value
The main factor affecting pearl prices is whether the pearl is natural or cultured. Both natural and cultured pearls are considered valuable because of their rarity, irreplicable luster, and the complex environmental conditions required for their formation over years. Determining the worth of a pearl involves assessing various factors such as type, size, shape, uniformity, color, luster, surface quality, and origin. The value of a pearl ranges depending on its unique characteristics and market demand.
Natural pearls are non-existent in today’s market and used to command much higher prices than cultured pearls. In fact, natural pearls are so scarce today that they rarely appear in retail settings and are primarily found in vintage jewelry, museums, or high-end auctions.
Cultured pearls make up the majority of pearls on the market today. And though they are more accessible than natural pearls, cultured pearls still require significant time, pristine environmental conditions, and careful harvesting to produce high-quality gems, making them valuable.
Price & Value by Pearl Type
Type is one of the factors that goes into determining pearl worth. Popular and expensive pearl types include:
South Sea Pearls
These saltwater pearls are considered the most valuable. They are produced in Australia, Indonesia, and the Philippines and are the largest pearl variety on the market (8-20mm). Available in white, silver, and golden colors, they command a few thousand dollars per high quality pearl and a few thousand dollars to a few hundred thousand dollars for a high-quality strand.
- Average-quality: $10,000+ per strand
- High-quality: $100,000+ per strand
- Individual pearls: $1,000+ each depending on quality
Tahitian Pearls
These exotic saltwater pearls have naturally dark hues ranging from green and gray to peacock tones. Depending on their size and quality, a strand of Tahitian pearls can cost a few hundred dollars to a few thousand dollars.
- Average-quality: $500+ per strand
- High-quality: $1,000+ per strand
- Individual pearls: $100+ each depending on quality
Akoya Pearls
These classic saltwater pearls are round and white with exceptional luster. They were the first pearls ever to be farmed and are typically smaller in size. A strand of Akoya pearls can cost from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars.
- Average-quality: $500+ per strand
- High-quality: $1,000+ per strand
- Individual pearls: $100+ each depending on quality
Freshwater Pearls
These versatile pearls come in a wide range of shapes, sizes, and colors and are typically the most affordable pearl type. Large, round freshwater pearls can closely resemble Akoya pearls but are more affordable, with a strand ranging from a few dollars to a few thousand dollars.
- Average-quality: $50+ per strand
- High-quality: $1,000+ per strand
- Individual pearls: $1+ each depending on size and quality
Price & Value by Pearl Quality
Six primary factors determine a pearl's value:
- Size: Larger pearls are more valuable than smaller ones when all other factors are equal. South Sea pearls, known for being the giant pearls in the world (ranging from 8-20mm), command higher prices due to their substantial size.
- Shape: Perfectly round pearls are rare and therefore more valuable, while off-round, baroque or irregularly shaped pearls may be more affordable. Only about 10% of a typical pearl harvest yields perfectly round specimens.
- Color: Pearl colors vary widely, from creamy whites to exotic shades like pink, blue, or black. The color of pearls can significantly enhance a pearl's value. Rare and vibrant pearl colors with strong overtones generally fetch premium prices.
- Luster: A pearl's luster — the intensity and sharpness of light reflected from its surface — is arguably the most important quality attribute. Fine quality pearls display bright and sharp reflections, giving them a mirror-like shine. The GIA recognizes five categories of luster from "excellent" (bright, sharp reflections) to "poor" (dim, diffused reflections).
- Surface Quality: Pearls with smooth, blemish-free surfaces are exceedingly rare and highly valued. Most pearls have some degree of imperfection, and fewer visible blemishes correlate with higher value.
- Nacre Thickness: Thick nacre contributes to a pearl's durability, luster, and overall value. The thicker the nacre is, the more lustrous and durable the pearl is — making the value go up. Thin nacre can result in poor luster and reduced longevity, significantly diminishing a pearl's worth.
When all these factors align perfectly — large size, round shape, rare color, excellent luster, clean surface, and thick nacre — a pearl's value increases exponentially. While some pearls cost just a few dollars, high-quality examples can be worth thousands.
Do Pearls Hold Their Value?
Pearls tend to hold their value fairly well compared to many other luxury items. High-quality pearls from reputable sources are particularly likely to maintain or even increase in value over time. This is why vintage pearl jewelry continues to be worth significant sums at auction today. For example, in 2018, a natural pearl pendant that once belonged to Queen Marie Antoinette auctioned at Sotheby's for $36.2 million, far exceeding its previous auction record. While not all pearls will appreciate so dramatically, high-quality pearls with proper documentation from reputable sources represent a wearable investment that can maintain or increase in value while providing beauty and enjoyment.
Several factors contribute to pearls' value retention:
- Durability: When properly cared for, pearls can last for generations
- Limited supply: High-quality pearls remain relatively scarce
- Timeless appeal: Pearl jewelry never goes out of style
- Historical significance: Notable pearls often have fascinating provenance
However, not all pearls maintain equal value. Factors that help ensure pearls retain their value include excellent initial quality (especially luster and surface condition), proper care and storage, and documentation of origin and quality.
