Start with Our Diamond Quiz
CZ vs. Diamond
Cubic zirconia (CZ) is a man-made stone, developed in the 1970s as a cost-effective diamond simulant. It is composed of zirconium dioxide and is created in a controlled lab environment. Cubic zirconia is known for its ability to mimic the look of a diamond while being available at a much lower cost. Cubic zirconia is not the same as natural diamonds or lab diamonds.
Diamonds are gemstones that form either under high pressure and temperature conditions deep within the Earth’s mantle or in controlled laboratory environments that mimic the natural process. They are composed mostly of carbon atoms arranged in a crystal lattice. This unique composition gives diamonds their extraordinary hardness and light performance.
When comparing CZ and diamond, several properties highlight their fundamental differences:
Appearance
At a glance, cubic zirconia and diamonds can appear similar. However, upon closer look, their differences become apparent. Diamonds have a higher refractive index than cubic zirconia, which means they tend to sparkle more intensely. Diamonds also display a sharper brilliance and distinct fire. Cubic zirconia tends to show a more pronounced rainbow-like effect, which can appear more artificial in certain lighting.
Another difference is that CZ stones are perfectly transparent, whereas most diamonds have natural inclusions or slight color variations. For those looking for a stone that mimics the “perfect” appearance, CZ may be appealing — but this perfection can also make it easier to distinguish from a real diamond, which often has minor imperfections that give it character.
Durability
One of the most significant differences between CZ and diamonds is their hardness. Diamonds are the hardest natural material on Earth, scoring a 10 on the Mohs hardness scale, which makes them highly resistant to scratching. This durability makes diamonds ideal for daily wear in engagement rings and other fine jewelry.
Cubic zirconia, by comparison, has a hardness of 8-8.5, meaning it is much more prone to scratching, chipping, and losing its luster over time. CZ is softer and more porous, so it can cloud or become dull with prolonged use, especially when exposed to chemicals or everyday wear and tear.
Price
Price is one of the most significant differences between cubic zirconia and diamonds. Cubic zirconia often costs a fraction of the price of a diamond. A 1-carat CZ stone may cost a few dollars, whereas a 1-carat diamond can range in the thousands, depending on factors such as cut, clarity, color.
When evaluating the total cost of ownership, consider that a quality diamond will likely maintain or even increase its value over time, while a cubic zirconia will gradually lose its aesthetic appeal and need replacement. For jewelry intended to last decades, this replacement cost should factor into the decision.
How to Tell the Difference Between Cubic Zirconia and Diamond
Cubic zirconia is manufactured to mimic the appearance of a diamond, so at a glance or when the stones are smaller, it can be hard to distinguish the two. But upon closer inspection there are a few easy ways to tell the difference between cubic zirconia and diamonds just by looking:
- Brilliance vs. Fire: Diamonds show balanced white light reflection with some color dispersion; CZ displays more rainbow effects and less white brilliance
- Flawless Appearance: CZ typically lacks the tiny natural inclusions present in almost all diamonds
- Color Differences: CZ may appear slightly gray or yellowish next to high-grade diamonds, and can become cloudy with wear
Diamond or Cubic Zirconia: Which Should You Choose?
The decision between diamond and cubic zirconia ultimately depends on your priorities, budget, and intended use.
When to Choose Diamond
- For Engagement Rings and Significant Occasions: Diamonds remain the traditional choice for engagement rings due to their symbolism, durability, and lasting value. Their ability to withstand decades of daily wear makes them ideal for this purpose.
- As an Heirloom: If you value jewelry as an investment or intend to pass pieces down through generations, diamonds offer substantial advantages in lasting value and durability.
- When Long-term Durability Is Essential: For pieces worn daily for years, diamonds offer unmatched scratch resistance and longevity.
When to Consider Cubic Zirconia
- For Fashion or Temporary Jewelry: For trendy styles that may fall out of fashion, cubic zirconia allows you to enjoy larger stones and more dramatic looks at a fraction of the cost.
- For Travel or High-Risk Situations: Many diamond owners use CZ "stand-ins" when traveling or in situations where loss or theft is a concern, keeping their valuable pieces secure at home.
- When Budget Is the Primary Concern: For those who prefer to allocate financial resources to other priorities (home purchase, education, experiences), cubic zirconia offers the diamond aesthetic without the substantial investment.
- For Rarely Worn Special Occasion Pieces: Jewelry worn only occasionally may not justify diamond pricing if the pieces won't face daily wear and tear.
Both options have legitimate advantages for different circumstances, and the right decision is the one that aligns with your values and lifestyle.
